| FIRST TEAM | |||
| AMIR CARTER | PCTI | 12 | OFFENSIVE LINE |
| JOE IMBASCIANI | LAKELAND | 12 | OFFENSIVE LINE |
| ZAIRE BETHEA | DEPAUL | 11 | OFFENSIVE LINE |
| AMID ADDISON | EASTSIDE | 12 | OFFENSIVE LINE |
| DEREK BASTINCK | WAYNE HILLS | 12 | OFFENSIVE LINE |
| ELIJAH DOLSON | PCTI | 12 | RUNNING BACK |
| KAREEM WALKER | DEPAUL | 11 | RUNNING BACK |
| XAVIER HARRIS | KENNEDY | 12 | RUNNING BACK |
| HASISE DUBOIS | DEPAUL | 11 | RECEIVER |
| JAKE CATALIOTO | LAKELAND | 11 | RECEIVER |
| ANTHONY MAZALEWSKI | PASSAIC VALLEY | 12 | RECEIVER |
| ZACH MAZALEWSKI | PASSAIC VALLEY | 12 | QUARTERBACK |
| KENNY ALSTON | PCTI | 12 | DEFENSIVE LINE |
| ANDRE EVANS | DEPAUL | 11 | DEFENSIVE LINE |
| KYLE BRACKETT | WAYNE HILLS | 12 | DEFENSIVE LINE |
| QUAYSHON ALEXANDER | DEPAUL | 11 | DEFENSIVE LINE |
| DREW LINDSAY | PCTI | 12 | LINEBACKER |
| AMIR ARRINGTON | DEPAUL | 12 | LINEBACKER |
| JUSTIN HOGAN | WAYNE HILLS | 12 | LINEBACKER |
| ERIK OSTLUND | WEST MILFORD | 12 | LINEBACKER |
| JACQUESE JOHNSON | PCTI | 12 | SECONDARY |
| DEKYRI MIMS | KENNEDY | 12 | SECONDARY |
| KWADIR BROWN | DEPAUL | 11 | SECONDARY |
| RAMIR TANN-DAVIS | EASTSIDE | 10 | SECONDARY |
| ZAIRE WEAVER | PCTI | 12 | OPEN |
| RYAN SHAFER | POMPTON LAKES | 12 | OPEN |
| ERIC JANKOWITZ | WAYNE VALLEY | 12 | KICKER |
| RYAN MCCABE | PASSAIC VALLEY | 12 | PUNTER |
| COACH-OF-THE-YEAR: | MATT DEMAREST, PCTI | ||
| SECOND TEAM | |||
| STEVEN STENECK | WEST MILFORD | 11 | OFFENSIVE LINE |
| NAAZIER LOVELY | KENNEDY | 11 | OFFENSIVE LINE |
| TOM IBRAHIM | PASSAIC VALLEY | 12 | OFFENSIVE LINE |
| FRANK PETRACCO | WAYNE HILLS | 12 | OFFENSIVE LINE |
| ANDREW FAILACE | DEPAUL | 12 | OFFENSIVE LINE |
| RYAN GOSIKER | POMPTON LAKES | 11 | OFFENSIVE LINE |
| NIK BAKALAIN | WEST MILFORD | 12 | RUNNING BACK |
| MARK DELUISE | WAYNE VALLEY | 12 | RUNNING BACK |
| DARIOUS MAXEY | MANCHESTER | 11 | RUNNING BACK |
| JAZHAIRE HICKMAN | KENNEDY | 11 | RECEIVER |
| COREY CURRAN | WEST MILFORD | 12 | RECEIVER |
| FREDDY GUIRAN | CLIFTON | 11 | RECEIVER |
| RYAN ADZIMA | DEPAUL | 12 | QUARTERBACK |
| JADRIEN TRAVIESO | WEST MILFORD | 12 DEFENSIVE LINE | |
| KEVIN DAVIS | CLIFTON | 12 DEFENSIVE LINE | |
| DYLAN ATIEH | PASSAIC VALLEY | 12 DEFENSIVE LINE | |
| MATT KNEPPER | HAWTHORNE | 12 DEFENSIVE LINE | |
| LEAMON HILLER | PASSAIC | 12 DEFENSIVE LINE | |
| MIKE DEITRICH | HAWTHORNE | 11 LINEBACKER | |
| STEPHAN LAZORCHACK | CLIFTON | 12 LINEBACKER | |
| KABIL PARKINSON | KENNEDY | 11 LINEBACKER | |
| JEREMY GRAY | PCTI | 12 LINEBACKER | |
| NOAH PROVENZANO | WEST MILFORD | 12 SECONDARY | |
| TERRELL VASSEL | DEPAUL | 11 SECONDARY | |
| NICKY MAHER | LAKELAND | 12 SECONDARY | |
| RYAN VANDERWERF | HAWTHORNE | 11 SECONDARY | |
| DAN MULLIN | LAKELAND | 11 OPEN | |
| KEITH MARTINEZ | PASSAIC VALLEY | 12 OPEN | |
| BILLY HALL | DEPAUL | 12 KICKER | |
| AARON FURNBACH | WEST MILFORD | 12 PUNTER | |
| HONORABLE MENTION | |||
| CLIFTON | JACOB ABILL | ADAM MIRANDA | |
| DEPAUL | JEREMY BROWN | ZACK BUTLER | |
| EASTSIDE | SHAWN SEABROOKS | JACOBY BLANFORD | |
| HAWTHORNE | LUKE BURKART | JAKE AGUERO | |
| KENNEDY | HOMAR CASTILLO | JACIIR MACK | |
| LAKELAND | KYLE NOVOTNY | SEAN MULLIN | |
| MANCHESTER | JUSTIN QUINTERO-ALICE | A ALEX MORALES | |
| PASSAIC | TYSHAWN BUNTING | DEVLYNN ALLEN | |
| PCTI | RAYQUAN STRAND | TODD DRYSDALE | |
| PASSAIC VALLEY | JAKE SLIKER | CHRIS ARMAGNO | |
| POMPTON LAKES | SAL NEGRINI | BRANDON FREDERICKSON | |
| WAYNE HILLS | JOE KENNY | BRIAN BERGES | |
| WAYNE VALLEY | ANDREW POPADICS | NICK GOODWIN | |
| WEST MILFORD | AUSTIN HOPLER | NICK LISA | |