| SOCCER TOURNAMENT HISTORY | ||
| YEAR | CHAMPIONS / CO-CHAMPIONS | SECOND PLACE |
| 1972 | Eastside | Clifton |
| 1973 | NO TOURNAMENT | |
| 1974 | Eastside | Kennedy |
| 1975 | Eastside (3) | Passaic |
| 1976 | Paterson Catholic (1) | Kennedy |
| 1977 | Clifton | Kennedy |
| 1978 | Wayne Hills | Wayne Valley |
| 1979 | Wayne Hills | Clifton |
| 1980 | Wayne Hills | Kennedy |
| 1981 | Wayne Valley | Kennedy |
| 1982 | Clifton | Kennedy |
| 1983 | Clifton | Wayne Hills |
| 1984 | Clifton | Wayne Hills |
| 1985 | Passaic Valley | Kennedy |
| 1986 | Lakeland | Wayne Hills |
| 1987 | Passaic Valley | Passaic |
| 1988 | Don Bosco Tech (1) / Lakeland | |
| 1989 | Lakeland (1) | Don Bosco Tech |
| 1990 | Passaic Valley | Clifton |
| 1991 | Passaic Valley (3) / Wayne Hills | co-champions |
| 1992 | Clifton / Wayne Valley | co-champions |
| 1993 | Clifton | Lakeland |
| 1994 | Clifton | Wayne Hills |
| 1995 | Wayne Hills | Pompton Lakes |
| 1996 | Kennedy | Pompton Lakes |
| 1997 | Clifton | Passaic Valley |
| 1998 | Clifton | Wayne Hills |
| 1999 | Clifton | Wayne Valley |
| 2000 | Clifton | Pompton Lakes |
| 2001 | Clifton | Wayne Valley |
| 2002 | Clifton | Wayne Hills |
| 2003 | Clifton | Pompton Lakes |
| 2004 | Clifton | Wayne Valley |
| 2005 | Clifton | Wayne Valley |
| 2006 | Wayne Valley | Clifton |
| 2007 | Wayne Valley | Clifton |
| 2008 | Clifton / Passaic County Tech (1) | co-champions |
| 2009 | Wayne Valley (5) | Passaic Valley |
| 2010 | Clifton 2 | Wayne Valley 1 |
| 2011 | De Paul Catholic 2 | Wayne Valley 1 |
| 2012 | Clifton 1 (19) | De Paul Catholic 0 |
| 2013 | Wayne Hills 2 (6) | Clifton 0 |
| 2014 | De Paul Catholic 2 (2) | Wayne Hills 1 |
| 2015 | Hawthorne Christian Academy 2 (1) | Wayne Valley 1 |
| 1st Team | |||
| Goal Keeper | Steven Beneventine | De Paul Catholic | 12 |
| Defender | Brendan Guzman | Clifton | 11 |
| Defender | Dan DiMaio | Wayne Valley | 12 |
| Defender | Kerome Hall | Eastside | 12 |
| Defender | Marco Ramos | Passaic | 12 |
| Defender | Jorge Galvez | Passaic Valley | 12 |
| Midfielder | Oscar Gonzalez | Clifton | 12 |
| Midfielder | John Gonzales | Passaic County Tech | 11 |
| Midfielder | Walther Castillo | Hawthorne | 11 |
| Midfielder | Enver Caymaz | Pompton Lakes | 10 |
| Midfielder | Nicola Mariella | De Paul Catholic | 12 |
| Forward | Erickson Simeon | Manchester | 12 |
| Forward | Valdrin Seci | Clifton | 12 |
| Forward | Joseph Corasaniti | Hawthorne | 12 |
| Forward | Teddy Forson | Passaic County Tech | 10 |
| Coach-of-the-Year: Ryan De Feo | Hawthorne | ||
| 2nd Team | |||
| GK | Andy Tsouhnikas | Clifton | |
| DEFENDER | Jose Borrajo | Clifton | |
| DEFENDER | Josh Basket | West Milford | |
| DEFENDER | Carlos Arevalo | Manchester | |
| DEFENDER | Frank Bruzzone | Lakeland | |
| DEFENDER | Ryan Machovsky | De Paul Catholic | |
| DEFENDER | Irvin Basauri | Passaic County Tech | |
| MIDFIELDER | Jamie Montero | Clifton | |
| MIDFIELDER | Noah Ruitenberg | Eastern Christian | |
| MIDFIELDER | Gilmark Costa | Kennedy | |
| MIDFIELDER | Keston Miguel | Eastside | |
| MIDFIELDER | Rafael Marques | Passaic Valley | |
| MIDFIELDER | Mike DeLuise | Wayne Valley | |
| MIDFIELDER | Jason Gold | Wayne Hills | |
| FORWARD | Erblin Ramani | De Paul Catholic | |
| FORWARD | Igor Petrovic | Clifton | |
| FORWARD | Juan Huaraca | Passaic County Tech | |
| FORWARD | Franco Jaime | Eastside | |
| HONORABLE MENTION | |||
| Clifton | Christian Castro | ||
| Clifton | Stephen Bienkiewicz | ||
| De Paul Catholic | Ivan Morales | ||
| De Paul Catholic | Xavier Graham | ||
| Eastern Christian | Jonathan Snack | ||
| Eastern Christian | Chad Miller | ||
| Eastside | Michael Laguna | ||
| Eastside | Kevin Viecco | ||
| Hawthorne | Sean Mulligan | ||
| Hawthorne | Trey Miller | ||
| Hawthorne Christian | Nicholas Lauda | ||
| Hawthorne Christian | Jody Lamb | ||
| Kennedy | Jim Flores | ||
| Kennedy | Carlos Alarcon | ||
| Lakeland | Matthew Mule | ||
| Lakeland | Erich Asan | ||
| Manchester | Devon Johnson | ||
| Manchester | Sambr Doghouz | ||
| PCTI | Bryan Parra | ||
| PCTI | Shan Massoud | ||
| Passaic | Jerry Tlatelpa | ||
| Passaic | Jose Calixto | ||
| Passaic Valley | Mike Libucha | ||
| Passaic Valley | Jon Cespedes | ||
| Pompton Lakes | Tommy Shannon | ||
| Pompton Lakes | Dave Kearney | ||
| Wayne Hills | Evan Baum | ||
| Wayne Hills | Max Zager | ||
| Wayne Valley | Robert Palmarozza | ||
| Wayne Valley | Kristian Gonzalez | ||
| West Milford | Robbie Vizcarra | ||
| West Milford | Jordan Carmichael |