| FIRST TEAM OFFENSE | ||
| Offensive Line | Jorge Vicioso | Passaic |
| Offensive Line | Heiberto Birto | Passaic County Tech |
| Offensive Line | Dwayne Bailery | Paterson Catholic |
| Offensive Line | Chris Fonti | Wayne Hills |
| Offensive Line | Brandon Castleboun | Wayne Valley |
| Tight End | Tyler Johnson | Lakeland |
| Receiver | Najee Salaam | Passaic |
| Receiver | Shakim Phillips | De Paul Catholic |
| Quarterback | Mike Quinn | Wayne Hills |
| Running Back | Domenick Coiro | Passaic Valley |
| Running Back | Brian Dowling | Wayne Hills |
| Running Back | Gregory Moore | Paterson Catholic |
| Fullback | Elijah Shumate | Paterson Catholic |
| FIRST TEAM DEFENSE | ||
| Defensive Line | Lafeit Frierson | Kennedy |
| Defensive Line | Inb Crenshaw | Paterson Catholic |
| Defensive Line | Ryan Salerno | Wayne Hills |
| Defensive End | Terman Phillips | Passaic County Tech |
| Defensive End | Trevor Clemmings | Paterson Catholic |
| Linebacker | Maximilian Wassel | Passaic Valley |
| Linebacker | Todd Anderson | Paterson Catholic |
| Linebacker | James Dedilectis | Wayne Hills |
| Linebacker | Jedd Blackowski | West Milford |
| Secondary | Terell Smith | Passaic County Tech |
| Secondary | Jacquiese Bacote | Paterson Catholic |
| Secondary | Matt DeBlock | Wayne Hills |
| FIRST TEAM SPECIALIST | ||
| Punter | Pete Savastano | Wayne Valley |
| Kicker | Tim Divers | Wayne Hills |
| Specialist | John Allard | Lakeland |
| Coach-of-the-Year | ||
| SECOND TEAM OFFENSE | ||
| Offensive Line | Scott Koningswood | Hawthorne |
| Offensive Line | Nicholas Kline | De Paul Catholic |
| Offensive Line | Alex Castillo | Manchester |
| Offensive Line | Tom Romeo | Passaic Valley |
| Offensive Line | Tyler Coyle | West Milford |
| Tight End | Dan Foesel | De Paul Catholic |
| Receiver | Logan Pevny | West Milford |
| Receiver | Keshon Brown | Kennedy |
| Quarterback | Jaqueiss Gerald | Paterson Catholic |
| Running Back | Isiah Loper | Eastside |
| Running Back | Taques Franklin | Manchester |
| Running Back | Jashon Dawson | Passaic |
| Fullback | Terrell McDuffie | Passaic County Tech |
| SECOND TEAM DEFENSE | ||
| Defensive Line | George Grosz | Clifton |
| Defensive Line | Craig Zimmer | De Paul Catholic |
| Defensive Line | Justin Cabrera | Passaic County Tech |
| Defensive End | Kyle Donnelly | West Milford |
| Defensive End | Nick Timminello | Wayne Hills |
| Linebacker | Jaiquan McCants | Kennedy |
| Linebacker | Jake McDonald | Lakeland |
| Linebacker | Lucas Broughton | Passaic County Tech |
| Linebacker | Jonathan Wozney | De Paul Catholic |
| Secondary | Brian Minorovich | Pompton Lakes |
| Secondary | Andre Dixon | Passaic |
| Secondary | Davon Jacobs | De Paul Catholic |
| SECOND TEAM SPECIALIST | ||
| Punter | Paul Mason | Pompton Lakes |
| Kicker | Jerry Veltri | West Milford |
| Specialist | Domenic Gianella | Hawthorne |
| HONORABLE MENTION | ||
| Mike Chiavetta | Clifton | |
| Dan Barlett | Clifton | |
| John Weiss | DePaul Catholic | |
| Kevin Stark | DePaul Catholic | |
| Allen Danstler | Eastside | |
| Rayshawn Gildon | Eastside | |
| Anthony Giannella | Hawthorne | |
| Tyler Johnson | Hawthorne | |
| Dwayne Pickett | Kennedy | |
| Orrett McBean | Kennedy | |
| Bobby Thompson | Lakeland | |
| Chris Deska | Lakeland | |
| Clint Apaza | Manchester | |
| Dennis Chapman | Manchester | |
| Oswal Ramos | Passaic | |
| Max Almonte | Passaic | |
| Lonnie Day | Passaic County Tech | |
| Andrew McCray | Passaic County Tech | |
| Dan Mesa | Passaic Valley | |
| Dan Webb | Passaic Valley | |
| Hennsey Henriquez | Paterson Catholic | |
| Khairi Harris | Paterson Catholic | |
| Shawn Patane | Pompton Lakes | |
| Anthony Pellegrini | Pompton Lakes | |
| Corey Mitchell | Wayne Hills | |
| Russ Piekarsky | Wayne Hills | |
| Ryan Young | Wayne Valley | |
| Andrew DeFillipis | Wanye Valley | |
| Tom Bailey | West Milford | |
| John Pierce | West Milford | |